Engine Saver Test Report

 

The following is a report on testing that was done to verify the performance of the P/N 2039  Engine Saver, and the P/N 2065 Black Max

 

A major cause of shortened engine life is water that forms inside an internal combustion engine when it is sitting. Water leads to RUST on the precision engine parts, and to the formation of sludge in the oil, both of which are harmful. From the minute you shut down, moisture starts to collect inside your engine. It is the result of  both the byproduct of combustion, and the daily changes in atmospheric temperature, humidity and barometric pressure. If the metal parts of the engine ever cool to a temperature that is lower than the dew point temperature on the air inside your engine, water droplets will form on the cool engine parts.  This same process that causes "dew" to collect on your automobile in the morning is collecting water inside your engine. If you can do something to upset this process of changing temperatures and humidity levels, (such as lowering the dew point temperature of the air inside the engine to a temperature considerably below the outside air temperature,) you can prevent water from ever forming inside your engine. This is what Our products do.

The Engine Saver is designed to supply a continuous flow of dry air into the crankcase of an aircraft engine. This lowers the dew point temperature of the air inside the engine to a value that is lower than the outside air temperature. With a dew point temperature inside the engine lower than the outside air temperature, water can never collect on the internal engine parts. A series of tests were done using a P/N 2039 Engine Saver to demonstrate that the system did significantly lower the humidity level inside the engine crankcase and in the upper cylinder area protecting all parts of the engine from water formation.

inserting the wand into the engine breather tube

Tests were performed on a Lycoming IO-360 engine. Testing were done in the early afternoon in September. The aircraft had been sitting for over 24hrs in a hangar. An Extech model 45320 humidity / temperature instrument was used to obtain data. This instrument measured relative humidity in %, and temperature in degrees F. The measured values were then converted to dew point temperatures as this form is easier to understand. An initial reading was taken to determine the temperature and humidity levels in the area around the engine. A relative humidity (RH) of 38% was measured. This corresponds to a dew point temperature of 60 degrees F. The dew point temperature is an important number. It is the temperature that the air must be cooled to, to cause moisture to form. In this initial reading, it was determined that air conditions were such that if the temperature of the outside air were cooled below 60 degrees F, water condensation would occur, and moisture would begin to form on surfaces. The oil stick was then removed, and the instrument inserted into the oil fill tube. Tape was used to prevent the entrance of outside air. A dew point temperature of 59 degrees F was measured in the engine crank case. A cardboard spacer with a small central hole was taped to the exhaust pipe to prevent the entrance of outside air into the exhaust pipe. The meter probe was inserted into the opening in the exhaust pipe, and again the dew point was found to be 60 degrees F. 

measuring initial conditions

The Engine Saver adapter and air tube was then inserted into the end of the engine breather tube where it extends from the bottom of the cowl. The tube was inserted in the breather sufficiently so that the foam washers were located above the ice hole in the breather, sealing it off from the outside air. The Engine Saver was then plugged in and allowed to run for 30 minutes. At the end of this time, the Engine Saver was turned off. The oil dipstick was again removed and the meter probe inserted into the oil fill tube and taped off. The meter indicated that after 30 minutes. of operation, the Engine Saver had dropped the humidity level in the crank case from a RH of 38% to 12%. This 12% RH corresponds to a dew point temperature of 28 degrees F. With the initial moisture level inside the engine crank case, had the outside air temperature dropped below 60 degrees F water condensation would occur. It is quite possible that this temperature could occur during the morning hours in the month of September, and water would then collect inside the engine. After running the Engine Saver for only 30 minutes, the dew point had dropped to 28 degrees F. There is little likelihood that the air temperatures would ever drop from 60 degrees at midday to 28 degrees on a September morning. The possibility that condensation would occur in the engine was significantly reduced after only 30 mins. of operation.measuring moisture level in the crank case

The next test was to measure the moisture level of the air in the exhaust pipe after the 30 minutes of Engine Saver operation. A measured reduction in moisture level of the air in the exhaust would prove that the dry air was migrating past the piston rings and into the upper cylinder area protecting this portion of the engine as well. The instrument probe was then inserted into the hole in the cardboard cover taped on the exhaust pipe, and the humidity level was measured. The moisture level was measured at 29% RH. This corresponds to a dew point of 48 degrees F indicating that the dry air was migrating past the piston rings and into the upper cylinder areas. Although the dew point was not as low as that measured in the crank case, it was still a significant reduction for only 30 minutes of operation. The outside air temperature would have to drop to 48 degrees F before condensation would occur.

measuring moisture levels in the exhaust pipeAn additional test was performed, only this time the Engine Saver was allowed to operate continuously for 24 hrs before the measurements were made. Measurements made in the oil fill tube gave a RH reading of 10%. This is below the minimum accurate reading on the meter scale. The actual RH reading was probably somewhat less than 10%, but was beyond the meters capability. The probe was then inserted into the exhaust pipe and a RH  measurement was made. The instrument read 10% at this point also. Since these measurements were below the low range capability of the meter, accurate dew point measurements could not be determined. However it is safe to say that the moisture level in the engine crank case and in the upper cylinder area was substantially reduced by the use of the Engine Saver, and the likelihood of moisture forming on the precision engine parts was substantially less than it would have been if nothing was done.

This testing verified that the Engine Saver functions as described. It reduced the dew point temperatures and the moisture level in the engine crank case and in the upper cylinder areas. Lower dew point temperatures means less chance of condensation occurring, and less chance of moisture forming and RUST developing. Different dew point temperatures would have been found if the tests were performed under different atmospheric conditions. The important thing is to look at the dew point temperature differences that were achieved by using the Engine Saver. The fact that the Engine Saver was able to achieve reductions in dew point temperatures can be translated directly into an extra margin against rust formation, and a greater chance of achieving TBO.

The P/N 2065 Black Max functions similarly to the P/N 2039 Engine Saver. The basic difference is in the way in which the lower dew point temperatures are achieved. The Black Max uses an electronic device instead of a chemical drying agent. to lower the dew point temperature of the air before it is pumped into the engine breather tube. The Black Max operates much like the dehumidifier used in a basement. ( Air is pumped over a cooling surface where it is cooled below its dew point temperature, water is condensed and collected, and the basement becomes dryer. ) The Black Max uses an electronic device to cool the air. This device has the ability to cool the air, and lower its dew point temperature, at least 40 degrees F. The actual dew point temperature that can be achieved is dependent on the outside air temperature. For example, if the outside air temperature starts at 100 degrees F, the dew point temperature of the air entering the engine would initially be lower than 60 degrees F. If the outside air temperature then drops from 100 degrees F to 60 degrees F, the dew point of the air coming from the Black Max would also drop by 40 degrees F to a temperature of about 20 degrees F. The Dew point temperature of the air coming from the Black Max is always lower than the outside air temperature. The unit runs continuously so that changes in outside air temperature would immediately cause a change in the dew point temperature of the air inside the engine crankcase. Levels of performance similar to that of the P/N 2039 Engine Saver can be expected from the Black Max.